https://www.fintechfutures.com/wp-content/themes/fintech_child/assets/images/logo/fintech-logo-2.png
  • Home
  • News
  • Intelligence
    • Back
    • Features & Analysis
    • Interviews
    • Reports & Surveys
    • White Papers
    • Case Studies
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Library
    • Techwire
    • Browse
  • Publications
    • Back
    • Banking Technology Magazine
    • Supplements
    • Daily News at Sibos
    • Subscribe to Magazine
  • Content Hub
    • Back
    • COVID-19: Industry Impact & Response
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Food for Thought
    • I’m Just Saying
    • The Heart of the Matter
    • Fintech Agony Uncle
    • It’s a Matter of Comms
    • Challenger Banks Guide
  • Videos
  • WTF? Podcast
  • Awards & Events
    • Back
    • Banking Tech Awards
    • Banking Tech Awards USA
    • PayTech Awards
    • FinTech Futures Edge: PayTech
    • All Events
  • Advertise
  • Jobs
  • More
    • Back
    • About us
    • Contact us
    • Advertising / Media Kit
    • Banking Technology Magazine Calendar
    • Reports Calendar
    • FinTech Futures Newsletter
  • FinTech
  • BankingTech
  • PayTech
  • RegTech
  • WealthTech
  • LendTech
  • InsurTech
  • US Edition
    • Intl. Edition
Banking Technology
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • News
  • Intelligence
    • Back
    • Features & Analysis
    • Interviews
    • Reports & Surveys
    • White Papers
    • Case Studies
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Library
    • Techwire
    • Browse
  • Publications
    • Back
    • Banking Technology Magazine
    • Supplements
    • Daily News at Sibos
    • Subscribe to Magazine
  • Content Hub
    • Back
    • COVID-19: Industry Impact & Response
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Food for Thought
    • I’m Just Saying
    • The Heart of the Matter
    • Fintech Agony Uncle
    • It’s a Matter of Comms
    • Challenger Banks Guide
  • Videos
  • WTF? Podcast
  • Awards & Events
    • Back
    • Banking Tech Awards
    • Banking Tech Awards USA
    • PayTech Awards
    • FinTech Futures Edge: PayTech
    • All Events
  • Advertise
  • Jobs
  • More
    • Back
    • About us
    • Contact us
    • Advertising / Media Kit
    • Banking Technology Magazine Calendar
    • Reports Calendar
    • FinTech Futures Newsletter
  • Search
  • US Edition
    • Intl. Edition
  • newsletter
  • FinTech
  • BankingTech
  • PayTech
  • RegTech
  • WealthTech
  • LendTech
  • InsurTech
fintechfutures.com


The end of the world (take two)?

  • Written by FinTech Futures
  • 1st February 2013

Tullett Prebon's Tim Morgan says the banking crisis is a symptom of impending catastrophe

Earlier this month, Banking Technology suffered a post-Mayan apocalypse shock. A weighty report landed on our desks, informing us that the global economy is likely finished, and that the end of civilisation is nigh.

Who would dare argue that a period of 200 years of economic expansion is coming to a close, and that recent banking sector headcount cuts are far from the worst we can expect in the tough times ahead? We couldn’t believe it.

And yet. Author Tim Morgan packs some impressive credentials. Currently global head of research at Tullett Prebon, his experience goes back  to 1982, when he left Emmanuel College, Cambridge for stockbrokers Wood Mackenzie. He has since served as an energy analyst at various banks and brokers including Banque Indosuez and Collins Stewart.

Morgan’s report becomes more disturbing the more one looks into the arguments provided to support its conclusion. The essential point is that our society is running out of energy. In 1990, the research says, it took one unit of energy to extract 40. Today, the ratio is barely 17:1 and is forecasted to decline below 10:1 in the coming decade. On this reading, debates such as the German Parliament’s plans to restrict high-frequency trading, or the European Commission’s upcoming MiFID II and EMIR legislation, are both merely tinkering at the edges of a problem that runs far deeper than market microstructure.

“The economy is a surplus energy equation, not a monetary one, and growth in output since the industrial revolution has resulted from the harnessing of ever-greater quantities of energy,” said Morgan. “But the critical relationship between energy production and the energy cost of extraction is now deteriorating so rapidly that the economy as we have known it for more than two centuries is beginning to unravel.”

At the heart of the doom-laden analysis set out by Morgan is the contention that there is a fundamental disconnection between the way modern society has concentrated on immediate consumption fuelled by spiralling debt, and the underlying production in the real economy.

In the US, for instance, debt grew by 390% in real terms between 1981 and 2009, whereas actual growth in GDP was 120% over the same period. Such a figure brings the debt ratio to 381%, a level unprecedented in history and surpassing even the 300% level reached in 1930 during the Great Depression.

The “madness of crowds”, Morgan suggests, led not just banks and asset managers but the whole of society to believe that house prices could only increase, and that borrowing against equity or spending it through equity release was a safe and rational way to behave. At the same time, globalisation saw corporations outsource their production to emerging economies. This boosted their own profits and the incomes of the minority at the top, while hollowing out the domestic economy through the export of skilled jobs.

“Outsourcing production was a self-inflicted disaster with few parallels in economic history,” said Morgan. “One would have to look back to a Spanish empire awash with bullion from the New World to find a combination of economic idiocy and minority self-interest equal to the folly of globalisation.”

So who is to blame? There has been widespread public vilification of bankers, and the Occupy Wall Street movement struck a chord with the estimated 50,000-100,000 marchers who converged on Time Square in New York last May. But the majority of bankers were only acting within the parameters of the debt-fuelled, immediate gratification ethos of the times, according to Morgan. Culpability belongs to our entire society.

Are we headed the same way as the ancient Romans?

Perhaps the most terrifying aspect of the equation is just how bad Tullett Prebon’s report suggests it can get. Returning to the concept that declining energy returns have aligned with the credit bubble and ensuing crash, the research warns that not only is the economy as we know it finished unless we can find another source of energy, but also that our very lives may be in question.

Two hundred years ago, the famous theorist Thomas Malthus predicted that population increases would lead to mass starvation. Humanity has defied that prediction by increasing food production faster than our own population levels. But in the last half century, that productivity has overwhelmingly depended on energy inputs provided mainly by fossil fuels – around 85% of the improvement, according to some estimates.

The implication is that without fossil fuels, food production would suffer a collapse of apocalyptic proportions. Such an outcome would mean more than just a banking crisis. It would mean the end of modern civilisation, the complete collapse of modern technology and ways of life, and a retreat to the dark ages.

And if you thought the west might be better placed than the developing world to cope with the stress, you’d better think again, according to the doom-laden document.

“The western developed nations are particularly exposed to the adverse trends explored in this report, because globalisation has created a lethal divergence between burgeoning consumption and eroding production, with out-of-control debt used to bridge this widening chasm.”

Food for thought…

Tags: Tullet Analysis, Industry Comment Worldwide

READ NEXT


  • Congratulations to the Banking Tech Awards USA 2022 winners!
  • FinTech Futures: Top five stories of the week – 20 May 2022
  • FinTech Futures Jobs: Your fintech job might change in the future
  • MarketFinance logo
    MarketFinance raises debt financing from Deutsche Bank

Leave a comment Cancel reply

-or-

Log in with your FinTech Futures account

Alternatively, post a comment by completing the form below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fintech Jobs


Related Content

  • Open banking – supporting businesses during a critical phase
  • Low-code development and BaaS APIs: is this embedded finance’s hockey stick moment?
  • Open Banking Expo Canada meet-ups launch virtually this June
  • PostFinance Switzerland picks FICO’s Falcon for fraud protection

Top stories

The hottest news this week

Click here to read

Magazine

Banking Technology Magazine May 2022 issue out now

2nd May 2022
view all

Webinars

Webinar: What are the top trends and technologies transforming financial services?

26th April 2022

Webinar: How to drive up digital completion rates with hybrid banking

1st April 2022

Webinar: Leveraging open banking to gain a holistic view of your clients’ finances

16th February 2022
view all

Fintech Jobs

Reports & Surveys

Report: Northern Ireland fintech – leaders in ESG

17th May 2022

FinTech Futures Industry Survey & Report 2022

6th May 2022

Report: Digital transformation and trends in financial services

6th May 2022
view all

Podcast

What the FinTech? | S.3 Episode 7 | The future of digital payments

12th May 2022

What the FinTech? | S.3 Episode 6 | Passwordless is more

28th April 2022

What the FinTech? | S.3 Episode 5 | AI in financial services

14th April 2022
view all

Videos

Video: Greg Palmer at Finovate Europe 2022 – The future of fintech

22nd April 2022

Video: JP Morgan at Finovate Europe 2022 – fostering innovation in payments

21st April 2022

Video: ING at Finovate Europe 2022 – the future of digital transformation for banks

20th April 2022
view all

White Papers

White paper: Digital lending – how technology transforms banks

17th May 2022

White paper: How to select a digital lending solution – the ultimate guide

17th May 2022

Report: Northern Ireland fintech – leaders in ESG

17th May 2022
view all

Events

PayTech Awards 2022

Find out more

Banking Tech Awards USA 2022

Find out more

Content Hubs

Sibos 2021 Content Hub

1st September 2021

The heart of the matter: a customer-centric look at fintech

4th August 2021

Diversity & Inclusion Hub

9th April 2021
view all

Media Packs

FinTech Futures Media Pack

Download

FinTech Futures Intelligence Media Pack

Download

Techwire

Cambridge Savings Bank Helps Local Business Owner Drive Impressive Growth with Commercial Lending Solution

21st May 2022

Zindigi Brings Pakistan’s Largest Tech Event – Future Fest 2022

21st May 2022

Inveniam Capital Partners and Rialto Markets Announce Partnership to Further Accelerate Adoption of Middle Market Corporate Capital Raises and Trading of Private Market Securities

20th May 2022

Marble Launches First Rewards-Based Mobile App For Insurance

20th May 2022

QRails Simplifies Earned Wage Access Delivery with Its AnyDay Platform

20th May 2022

Identifee Partners With Nacha Consulting to Develop User-Friendly ACH Education Videos

20th May 2022

Auto fintech Caribou raises $115 million in Series C funding, valuing company at $1.1 billion

20th May 2022

medZERO Continues to Sign up Innovative Companies Wanting to Offer Expanded Benefits to Attract and Retain Employees in Competitive Market

20th May 2022
view all

Twitter

FinTech_Futures

RT @bondfintech: Thanks to @FinTech_Futures for the Best Embedded Finance Initiative award! 🏆 Couldn't have done it without our awesome par…

20th May 2022
FinTech_Futures

Programmable banking We are fast approaching the time finally being right for programmable #banking. fintechfutures.com/2022/05/progra…

20th May 2022
FinTech_Futures

Congratulations to the #BankingTechAwardsUSA 2022 winners! Take a look at the 2022 Banking Tech Awards winners fintechfutures.com/2022/05/congra…

20th May 2022
FinTech_Futures

FinTech Futures: Top five stories of the week – 20 May 2022 Here’s our pick of five of the top news stories from t… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

20th May 2022
FinTech_Futures

.@MarketFinance raises debt financing from @DeutscheBank The company says the funds will be used to provide up to… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

20th May 2022
FinTech_Futures

ICYMI #fintech funding round-up: @CertifID, @mybridgecard & Forward A handy round-up of the recent funding endeavo… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

20th May 2022
FinTech_Futures

.@Finovate Spring 2022: @StarlingBank CEO Anne Boden on what big banks can do better Starling Bank CEO Anne Boden… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

20th May 2022
FinTech_Futures

.@LSEGplc to acquire market data solutions provider @MayStreetTech The acquisition is expected to close in H1 202… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

20th May 2022

Sign up for the FinTech Futures newsletter

Receive updates straight to your inbox each day

New issue of Banking Technology Magazine out now

Available to download for free

PayTech Awards 2022 – The Shortlist

Congratulations to all of this year's finalists!

FinTech Futures Jobs

Find a job or post a vacancy

Fintech Futures
  • About us
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us
  • Fintech jobs
  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2022 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.
This website uses cookies, including third party ones, to allow for analysis of how people use our website in order to improve your experience and our services. By continuing to use our website, you agree to the use of such cookies. Click here for more information on our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
X