https://www.fintechfutures.com/wp-content/themes/fintech_child/assets/images/logo/fintech-logo.png
  • Home
  • COVID-19
  • News
  • Intelligence
    • Back
    • Analysis
    • Interviews
    • Features
    • White Papers
    • Case Studies
    • Surveys, Reports & Infographics
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Library
    • Techwire
    • Browse
  • Publications
    • Back
    • Banking Technology Magazine
    • Supplements
    • Daily News at Sibos
    • Subscribe to Magazine
  • Content Hub
    • Back
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • COVID-19: Industry impact & response
    • Challenger Banks Guide
    • Food For Thought
    • I’m Just Saying
    • Through a Gen Z Lens
    • Vlog: It’s a matter of comms
    • Fintech Agony Uncle
    • Ask The Expert
  • Videos
  • WTF? Podcast
  • Awards
    • Back
    • Banking Technology Awards
    • PayTech Awards
  • Digital Events
  • Advertise
  • Jobs
  • More
    • Back
    • About us
    • Contact us
    • Advertising / Media Kit
    • Banking Technology Magazine Calendar
    • Reports Calendar
    • FinTech Futures Newsletter
    • Events
  • FinTech
  • BankingTech
  • PayTech
  • RegTech
  • WealthTech
  • LendTech
  • InsurTech
  • US Edition
    • Intl. Edition
Banking Technology
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • COVID-19
  • News
  • Intelligence
    • Back
    • Analysis
    • Interviews
    • Features
    • White Papers
    • Case Studies
    • Surveys, Reports & Infographics
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Videos
    • Library
    • Techwire
    • Browse
  • Publications
    • Back
    • Banking Technology Magazine
    • Supplements
    • Daily News at Sibos
    • Subscribe to Magazine
  • Content Hub
    • Back
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • COVID-19: Industry impact & response
    • Challenger Banks Guide
    • Food For Thought
    • I’m Just Saying
    • Through a Gen Z Lens
    • Vlog: It’s a matter of comms
    • Fintech Agony Uncle
    • Ask The Expert
  • Videos
  • WTF? Podcast
  • Awards
    • Back
    • Banking Technology Awards
    • PayTech Awards
  • Digital Events
  • Advertise
  • Jobs
  • More
    • Back
    • About us
    • Contact us
    • Advertising / Media Kit
    • Banking Technology Magazine Calendar
    • Reports Calendar
    • FinTech Futures Newsletter
    • Events
  • US Edition
    • Intl. Edition
  • newsletter
  • FinTech
  • BankingTech
  • PayTech
  • RegTech
  • WealthTech
  • LendTech
  • InsurTech

bankingtech.com

bankingtech.com


MiFID II is a “dog’s dinner” says former UK government advisor

  • Written by FinTech Futures
  • 16th April 2013
Cliff: MiFID II shows a lack of understanding

Cliff: MiFID II shows a lack of understanding

While HFT may pose a real threat to market stability, the European Commission’s response has been woefully inadequate and shows a lack of understanding of the core issues, says professor Dave Cliff of the University of Bristol, a former member of the UK government’s Foresight Project.

“MiFID II represents the worst form of tokenistic politics,” Cliff told delegates at the TradeTech conference in London on Tuesday. “The politicians are quick to jump on the bandwagon and shout that something must be done, but the legislation is so poorly thought out, it’s idiotic.”

Fears that HFT may have been responsible for the flash crash of 6 May 2010, in which $1 trillion was briefly wiped from the value of the US stock market, have prompted regulators around the globe to explore new controls designed to rein in the practice. Yet according to Cliff, regulators in both Europe and the US have a poor record of analysing the evidence. US regulator the Securities and Exchange Commission still has yet to provide a satisfactory explanation of what took place, he insists.

“It took five months for a final report, and within a few weeks of that, it became clear from research by Nanex that the SEC and CFTC analysis is not supported by the facts,” he said.

Last November, the Foresight Project published a document examining the effects of computerised trading on financial markets. The Foresight study concluded that there is no evidence that HFT adversely affects the quality of markets, and was critical of measures contained in the EC’s MiFID II document.

Under current proposals, MiFID II would introduce a minimum resting time of 500 milliseconds for all orders in the market. However, Cliff does not believe the measures contained in MiFID II stand up to serious scrutiny. The move has been widely condemned by market participants, who have pointed out it would simply make long-term institutional investors even more vulnerable to aggressive predatory HFT strategies.

That said, Cliff does acknowledge that there is a problem. Referring to a host of market crashes in recent years, including the BATS IPO and the Knight Capital trading glitch, in which the company lost $400 million due to a rogue algorithm in minutes, he warned that the market is suffering from a process called ‘normalisation of deviance’, in which events that were originally never supposed to happen gradually come to be accepted due to an apparent lack of serious consequences.

“We are in danger of falling into a situation where no-one has an overall view – and that’s when accidents happen,” he said. “Our research has shown that HFT works well 99% of the time – but the potential consequences of that 1% could be serious.”

Observing that the financial markets have divided into a market we can interact with on a human timescale, and a high-speed market where machines can interact, he suggests that coordinated circuit breakers across multiple trading venues, and coordinated European tick sizes, would be useful measures to help maintain stability. He also suggests that synchronised time stamps could serve as the basis of a consolidated audit trail, helping to provide more transparency for market participants and regulators alike.

“The problem with MiFID II is it’s done really badly because it’s done by politicians,” he said. “They need to be held to account and educated. We need to engage with the politicians, because that’s the only way we are going to get the clear thinking that we need.”

MiFID II is the European Commission’s attempt to make sense of changes to financial markets since the original MiFID opened up Europe’s equity markets to competition in 2007. The document is intended to bring harmony to the 27 member states of the European Union. It also aims to extend the scope of the legislation to other asset classes such as FX and fixed income. MiFID II is expected to take effect in 2015/16, based on current estimates from the European Parliament.

Tags: Compliance, Regulation, Trading Technology Dave Cliff, Foresight Project News Worldwide

Leave a comment Cancel reply

-or-

Log in with your FinTech Futures account

Alternatively, post a comment by completing the form below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related


  • Barclays to close Pingit after 10 years’ service
    Long-serving payments app to be shut down by major UK bank.
  • Modulr lands undisclosed investment from FIS Ventures
    “Modulr lowers the barriers to bringing payments into a platform".
  • Laurel Road
    KeyBank launches digital bank for doctors with new offshoot at Laurel Road
    KeyBank acquired Laurel Road in 2019.
  • Howard Moore Mobiquity
    Mobiquity hires former BNP Paribas COO Howard Moore
    Digital transformation firm plans to expand globally this year and beyond.
  • MyLife MyFinance goes live on cloud hosted Temenos technology
    Australian bank deploys Transact in the cloud with SaaS package.
  • Nigerian fintech Appzone lands $10m for pan-African digital core banking solution
    The Series A round was led by CardinalStone Capital Advisers.
  • Finder snaps up shuttered Singapore fintech GoBear
    COVID-19 took a toll on GoBear’s capital reserves and certain financial products.
  • Dutch personal finance app Paynote goes live with beta
    Unlike its rivals, Paynote launches without bank support.

Related Content

  • Minna Technologies recruits Tiama Hanson-Drury as new product officer
  • EML Payments acquires open banking brand Nuapay in €110m deal
  • Tide signs deal with RBL Bank to underpin Indian expansion
  • France's central bank warns fintech industry of rules when using term "neobank"

Dock - virtual roundtables

Dock is free to attend for banks and FIs

Click here to register

Sponsorship opportunities available at Dock

Click here for more info

Magazine

Banking Technology April issue out now

8th April 2021

Banking Technology March issue out now

12th March 2021
view all

Webinars

Webinar: Getting to market faster by outsourcing PCI compliance

23rd March 2021

Webinar: Balancing app innovation and cybersecurity in financial services

5th March 2021

Webinar: How to stop massive mobile banking fraud with app security and risk-based authentication

9th February 2021
view all

Reports & Surveys

FinTech Futures Industry Survey & Report 2021

4th March 2021

Report: The power of data analytics in fintech solutions

25th February 2021

Omdia Universe 2020-21: Temenos recognised as a leader for digital banking platforms

15th December 2020

Report: Digital KYB – a springboard to customer onboarding success

30th November 2020
view all

Content Hubs

Diversity & Inclusion Hub

9th April 2021

Dear Luc: your most pressing fintech problems solved by our Agony Uncle

8th April 2021

Vlog: It’s a matter of comms

30th March 2021

COVID-19: industry impact & response

26th June 2020
view all

Podcast

What the Fintech? | S.2 Episode 8 | Bank branches amid COVID-19

8th April 2021

What the Fintech? | S.2 Episode 7 | Class is in session

19th March 2021

What the Fintech? | S.2 Episode 6 | Open banking on the loose

5th March 2021
view all

Videos

Video: Top fintech stories this week – 16 April 2021

16th April 2021

Video: Top fintech stories this week – 9 April 2021

9th April 2021

It’s a matter of comms | Episode 3 | ESG

23rd March 2021

Video: Top fintech stories this week – 18 March 2021

21st March 2021
view all

White Papers

Embedded insurance: a $3tn market opportunity, that could also help close the protection gap

4th January 2021

White paper: The business value of ServiceNow for retail banks

12th December 2020

E-book: Migration to cloud – your guide to delivering an intuitive customer experience

8th December 2020

White paper: Re-wiring financial services operations for a bold future

7th December 2020
view all

Techwire

PacWest Bancorp Announces Results for the First Quarter of 2021

20th April 2021

Orrstown Financial Services, Inc. Reports First Quarter 2021 Results

20th April 2021

True Return Systems LLC and D. Tiller Law PLLC Commence Sale of Foundational Blockchain Patent as a Non-Fungible Token (NFT)

20th April 2021

Esker Recognized as a Market Leader in Ardent Partners 2021 ePayables Technology Advisor for Second Consecutive Year

20th April 2021

Commerce Home Mortgage’s Wholesale Division Has a New Name: Change Wholesale

20th April 2021

Commerce Home Mortgage Has a New Name: Change Home Mortgage

20th April 2021

LifeYield Helped Advisors Create $2.9B of Potential Retirement Wealth in Q1 2021

20th April 2021

StratiFi & Wealthbox Announce Integration Partnership

20th April 2021
view all

Twitter

FinTech_Futures

Hospitality payment app @sunday_please raises record €20m seed round for Europe fintechfutures.com/2021/04/hospit…

21st April 2021
FinTech_Futures

.@signifyd raises $205m in Series E featuring @FISGlobal fintechfutures.com/2021/04/signif…

21st April 2021
FinTech_Futures

.@Hi55Ventures, @GlobalNTT DATA, @railsbank and @Mastercard team up to reinvent payroll fintechfutures.com/2021/04/hi55-v…

21st April 2021
FinTech_Futures

Development Bank of Wales [@devbankwales] picks EQ Credit Services for lending [@equiniti] fintechfutures.com/2021/04/develo…

21st April 2021
FinTech_Futures

.@Mastercard acquires digital identity firm .@EkataGlobal in $850m deal fintechfutures.com/2021/04/master…

21st April 2021
FinTech_Futures

FinTech Futures & @getVGS are hosting an exclusive #webinar tomorrow on Getting to Market Faster by Outsourcing… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

21st April 2021
FinTech_Futures

How much do subscription services invest in chargeback protection and why do they need it? "There is a way to both… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

20th April 2021
FinTech_Futures

Low-code start-up @fintech_os lands €51m Series B fintechfutures.com/2021/04/low-co…

20th April 2021

Dock: virtual roundtable experience like no other

18-19 May 2021; FREE TO ATTEND

US Challenger banks: who's who & what's their tech

Free to read

FinTech Futures Industry Survey & Report 2021

A deep-dive into the trends defining 2021 and beyond. FREE DOWNLOAD

Free webinar: Getting to market faster by outsourcing PCI compliance

22 April 2021, register today!

Fintech Futures
  • About us
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact us
  • Fintech jobs
  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2021 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.
This website uses cookies, including third party ones, to allow for analysis of how people use our website in order to improve your experience and our services. By continuing to use our website, you agree to the use of such cookies. Click here for more information on our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
X