Blog: Blackhawk IPO and the Value of Prepaid Distribution
By John Grund, First Annapolis Consulting
Safeway’s decision to IPO a minority stake of Blackhawk Network is yet another milestone in the evolution of the prepaid industry, given Blackhawk’s unique distribution role in the broader value chain. Green Dot and NetSpend serve as bell weathers for the market value of program managers in the prepaid value chain, but the importance of distribution is evident in their respective business models. However, the two largest distribution players—InComm and Blackhawk—are privately/closely held (although Warburg Pincus recently made a minority investment in InComm) and among the most interesting companies in prepaid. It’s important to note that both InComm and Blackhawk are more than pure play distribution entities given the technology, products/services and platforms resident in each company. That being said, both enjoy highly advantaged positions in the prepaid value chain given the dynamics of distribution and as an affiliate of Safeway, Blackhawk is particularly unique in that regard.
Any IPO (or investment in the case of InComm/Warburg Pincus) is fundamentally a story about future growth, which begs the question on the direction of third-party distribution. Will consumers adopt mobile in a way that shifts card acquisition from physical distribution in any meaningful way? Will Blackhawk and InComm be major players in the mobile wallet space and be able to transfer their strengths in physical distribution to the digital space? Can physical distribution be leveraged in ways beyond prepaid to open up entirely new growth vectors? Is the runway for international growth robust? Will entirely new third party distribution models emerge with the likes of Facebook, Groupon, Amazon, etc.? Can a retailer-led initiative such as MCX (Merchant Customer Exchange) eventually be a platform for gift card distribution? Will some combination of forces drive distribution margins down over time?
The market will be the ultimate judge, but to date, distribution-based business models have been resilient and impressive. According to management, Blackhawk generated $62 million in pre-tax income for 2011, a 64 percent increase over the previous year, and even stronger metrics are anticipated for this year.
Safeway’s decision to take Blackhawk public is a classic case of unlocking value given the P/E differential between a grocer and a high-growth, high-margin company with low capital intensity. Blackhawk has an enviable market share with more than 72,000 distribution locations and drove just under $7 billion in load value in 2011. Blackhawk has a commanding share of grocery distribution and, ironically, has successfully established relationships with direct competitors of Safeway. The reach of its distribution network and share of the grocery channel allowed Blackhawk to secure certain relationships on an exclusive basis at attractive margins. Over the course of time, the cost of and debate over third party distribution is always high on retailer agendas given their thin margins and different views on incremental sales, but to many it is a cost of doing business unless and until the market changes.
While overall market conditions have improved for IPOs in general, Green Dot’s recent earnings miss and lowered guidance have given pause to investors that have been riding the wave of prepaid. That said, Blackhawk has a unique model with large-scale distribution, access to millions of customers a day in foot traffic, a self-managed line of open-loop prepaid products and distribution arrangements with market leaders across verticals. In our view, distribution remains the most defensible link in the prepaid value chain as even the best products cannot overcome weak distribution.
|Figure 1: Blackhawk at a Glance|
Source: Goldman Sachs 2012 Global Retailing Conference, company websites and press releases, and Safeway 2011 Annual Report
John Grund is a partner at First Annapolis, specializing in retailer-based financial services. One of his principal specialties is the formation and growth of financial services partnerships between leading financial institutions and market leaders in the retail, grocery, airline, hotel, automobile and technology sectors. He may be reached at [email protected].
If you’d like to comment on this blog post, please join the conversation on our Paybefore LinkedIn Group.
View our other posts here.